Not only popular because of the Real housewives of NJ but also because it's amazing. Super delicious and fresh. Fast service with lots of workers. Parking lot available. Great spot for dessert and worth the trip, Cheers.

Tried and true! I've been coming to Gelotti's for well over 20 years. Creamy which means it doesn't have a lot of stabilizer. Delicious flavors with tons of to choose from. It's definitely a must if you're in the surrounding area! Service is quick and easy.

Even though this place is in Patterson, it is worth the drive. The ice cream is made fresh and so creamy. The service and staff are extremely nice and the ambience is just as amazing. I love the cannoli one.!!!

I recently visited Gelotti for the second time, and once again, it did not disappoint! Despite being very busy, the lines moved quickly, thanks to the efficient staff. My strawberry milkshake was absolutely divine, and everyone in my group loved their gelato. There are countless flavors and items to choose from, so there's something for everyone. The quality and flavor of the treats are consistently excellent. I highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area!

Went here on a Saturday morning and place was not too busy. Was able to test a few flavors and the servers were really helpful in the flavor selection. The inside had an array of menus and selections. was overwhelming but in a good way. A good gelato experience and tastes great.

The best ice cream ever! I always get the mint Oreo and it's delicious! They offer cookies and gelato as well! Service is always great and I love that there is a decent amount of parking! Clean atmosphere as well!

First full day of spring had us stopping by Gelotti's. This place is historic and they remodeled it recently and it looks great. The service here is always good. There wasn't a line during this visit but even when there is they move relatively quick. The ice cream is delicious and the sprinkles to top it off bring me back to my childhood. Definitely recommend stopping by this ice cream spot if you're in the area. My kids love it as well. Sign up for their rewards!

I've never been here but have heard plenty about it, so gave it a shot this Summer Sunday night. The place was pretty packed with a lot of family's but the line moved quickly. I got a vanilla chocolate soft serve and my family got sugar free vanilla chocolate chip and another soft serve. From a soft serve perspective, I thought it was very good and would go back for it, but it wasn't as excellent as it was talked up to be; however, the hard ice cream may live up to the hype from what I heard. One problem I did notice was the quantity I received differed significantly from another patrons. I got a medium and as my picture shows, it was certainly a hefty, good sized medium for the $5 it cost, and totally worth it. The customer next to me got a medium that barely toppled over the side of the cup and then asked to upgrade to a large. Now I do understand the kids working behind the counter are just doing the job the best they can and servers can vary with this but hopefully addressing it in this post allows management to teach their team how to have (somewhat) even portions. If I was that customer I would've been a bit disappointed. I'm hoping my constructive criticism helps out everyone else!

It could be 2 degrees in the middle of the winter and I would still make the line at Gelottis for some good old ice cream! So this time around I got the coffee ice cream in a junior size (just enough to satisfy my sweet tooth) with some chocolate chips. TO DIE FOR. I usually get their coffee chip, which already has the chocolate chips in them, but they were out. Their Italian ice is also amazing! All the flavors are pretty good, but their strawberry and mango are must tries!